Category Archives: Book Review

New Appalachian Trail Maps – A review

NatgeoATmapsWe all know about the quality of National Geographic maps. Here in Western North Carolina, hikers depend on NatGeo maps for Pisgah National Forests and Great Smoky Mountains National Park trails.

Now comes a 13-map set, which covers the 2,190 miles of the Appalachian Trail. As befitting the quality of NatGeo products, these maps are on rugged waterproof, tear-resistant paper. You can buy individual map booklets for the section you’re going to hike. Each map retails for $14.95.

However, here’s the best part about these maps. Most conventional maps are printed on one large, unwieldy sheet of paper. I find it difficult to manage these map in the wind or rain – and then I have to fold it up and it’s a mess.

image_preview2Instead these new maps have been organized into a small book. When folded, the guide is similar in size to most NatGeo Trail Maps: 4.25″ x 9.25″.

Not only is this a much easier format to handle on the trail, it also allows hikers to know exactly what page to look for their next piece of trail. The map set is complete, even though NatGeo also produces a conventional map of the Smokies and Shenandoah National Park.

I looked carefully at the Carolina Mountain Club (and Tennessee Eastman Hiking and Canoeing Club) section: Davenport Gap to Damascus. Most of the front part of the booklet is repeated throughout the other maps, including information about the visionary Benton MacKaye, Rules and Regulations, Leave No Trace principles, and the role of the Appalachian Trail Conservancy.

Lenny weedwacking
Lenny weedwacking

But before the hiker is tempted to just tear out those pages to save weight, she should look more carefully. First, and this is the part I love. They give credit to CMC and TEHCC. It says:

Volunteers of the Carolina Mountain Club and the Tennessee Eastman Hiking and Canoeing Club provide trail and shelter maintenance and management between the Virginia-Tennessee border and Davenport Gap.

Camping options are listed along with their capacity and map pages for each booklet. There’s a small map of the principal towns, in this case, Hot Springs and Damascus.

Then comes the actual map sections. Any hiker familiar with NatGeo maps of any park or forest will recognize the trail markings and mileage between sections. An extra bonus is the elevation profile at the bottom of each page. Like any other profile, the hiker/reader needs to note the scale. In the first few pages, the altitude range goes from 2,000 to 7,000 feet. Toward the end of the map section, it’s 2,000 to 5,000.

Some room for improvement, if I may.

* I couldn’t find any mention or acknowledgement that the A.T. is a national park unit, specifically, the Appalachian National Scenic Trail.

* Though the front of the booklets talk about the “unique partnership” between the US Forest Service, the National Park Service, A.T.C., it is the land manager of the section you’re walking on that decides the rules. As a corollary, in the section which includes the Smokies, the “no dogs on the trail” rule should have been highlighted.

* The map section has page numbers, the booklet could also use page numbers for text.

All in all, a major improvement on the old A.T. maps and a great purchase for both long-distance and day-hikers.

How to Talk About Places You’ve Never Been – Book Review

bayard9781620401378How to Talk About Places You’ve Never Been: On the Importance of Armchair Travel by Pierre Bayard

When I first read the title, I thought that it was a humor book. But it isn’t. Bayard’s book praises writers and “adventurers” who’ve not been to the places they talk about.

He claims that the role of fiction in the travelogue discourages people from traveling. They learn what they wanted to know about a place. Why put out the effort? Really?

How far did Marco Polo get? Maybe no further than Venice, according to Bayard. And how about Margaret Mead? She did go to Samoa and wrote Coming of Age in Samoa, which made her world famous. But according to Bayard, she didn’t stay with the local population for long. Therefore she came up with conclusions that Samoan teenagers were much freer with sex than their American counterparts. This was refuted in the 1980s.

Bayard spends too much time with Jayson Blair, the NY Times journalist who faked his stories. He was caught, shamed and fired but Bayard seems to redeem him. Same with Rosie Ruiz, the woman who took the NYC subway during the New York City marathon. If you read the chapter on Ruiz’ ruse in a certain way, you can say that Bayard understands and even condones her behavior.

Rev War Patriot at the Battle of Kings Mountain
Rev War Patriot at the Battle of Kings Mountain

The main reason I read the book cover to cover is that Bayard seems to explain and even praise the exact opposite of what I do. I won’t write about some place I haven’t been to.

Even if I get most of my information from the web and think I understand it, I need to go there. He talks about the spirit of the place.

What you can see when you travel may be “disconnected fragments of reality” or “common places devoid of interest”, he says. But I disagree. Common places are interesting, if you spend time in them. I’ve been to many, many national park service battlefields, by now. And they’re all different and interesting.

You got to get out more, Prof. Bayard. I’ll save armchair travel for when I’m really old.

Hiking South Carolina’s Foothills Trail – A review

FrontOnlyFoothillsIt’s fashionable to believe that hiking guides are no longer necessary because everyone has a cell phone, an app, and the web. However, nothing can beat a book or map in your pack.

Maybe hiking guides no longer have to sell you on the hike. No need to wax poetic about the beauty of the waterfall or the view. We can leave this to the web. And it’s not a bad place to get hiking ideas.

But when it comes to the actual turn-by-turn directions and how to find the trailhead, we all need the accuracy of a guidebook. So it is with the Foothills Trail (FHT).

The FHT is a 76.2-mile national recreation trail from Table Rock State Park to Oconee State Park in upstate South Carolina. In between, it crosses into Western North Carolina. The trail features waterfalls, lakes, rivers, and Sassafras Mountain, the highest mountain in South Carolina. So how long would it take you to walk the distance?

For that, you need to pick up Hiking South Carolina’s Foothills Trail by Scott Lynch. The book shows you that you could do it in five days, averaging 15.3 miles, or six days (12.7 miles per day) or seven days, (10.8 miles a day). All of this is figured out for you. Lynch tells you where to start and end and where to camp in between. In addition, the author highlights the crown jewel section in the middle. Concise directions are given from either direction.

But what if you don’t want to backpack? No problem. The guide offers clear directions to major and minor trailheads, so you can plan a dayhike.

Top of Sassafras Mt.
Top of Sassafras Mt.

Yesterday, I led a Carolina Mountain Club hike on the FHT to Sassafras Mountain and back. Usually, I photocopy the pages I need but this pocket guide is the perfect size to put in your pack or even your pocket.

Scott Lynch is a former outdoor guide who’s written other books on the area. With a guidebook, it’s also important to look at the publisher, Milestone Press.

They’ve been publishing outdoor guides for over twenty years. Their books are well done, clear, and most important to me, they’re accurate at the time of publication.

It might seem like a lot of money on a per page basis. But you’re paying for a book that’s also an annotated map. Therefore, you get a map and book, together. Quite a good deal.

The Details
Hiking South Carolina’s Foothills Trail, Paperback by Scott Lynch
72 pages, $16.95 Publisher: Milestone Press, 2015 ISBN-13: 978-1889596303